Blog Post

Israel’s annexation plans: Now, never or later?

Colin Mitchell • Jun 17, 2020

‘But now, thus says the Lord who created you O Jacob, and He who formed you O Israel: “Fear not, for I have redeemed you; I have called you by your name; You are Mine”’ – Isaiah 43:1

Israel’s Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, has been saying that by 1st July this year he will annex Israeli settlements in Judea and Samaria (often called the West Bank), and the area of the Jordan Valley that lies strategically along the Jordanian border.

The much-heralded Trump Peace Plan allocates these territories to Israel as part of a negotiated settlement with the Palestinian Authority. Netanyahu’s coalition government has made plans to unilaterally annex these areas, irrespective of an agreement with Mahmoud Abbas and the Palestinian Authority.

The Netanyahu administration’s reason for this move is that they think it best to complete the annexation while Trump is still in office to increase the chances of US government support. With a US presidential election looming in November, no one knows whether Trump will be re-elected, so Netanyahu’s administration is trying to plan strategically.

If Joe Biden is elected, there will be no support at all from the US. So, the idea is to act now and avoid US opposition.

The thinking also goes that no amount of negotiation with the PA will bring a resolution They have already categorically rejected the Trump Peace Plan. So, the only way to secure the disputed territories is the annex them now.

It is clear that the PA and Abbas are just as committed to Israel’s destruction as the Hamas terrorists who rule Gaza, and the Iranians, whose proxy terrorists, Hezbollah, dominate Lebanon.

From a biblical perspective, God has already gone on record about how He views His land:

‘…but the land [Israel] which you cross over to possess is a land of hills and valleys, which drinks water from the rain of heaven, a land for which the Lord your God cares; the eyes of the Lord your God are always on it, from the beginning of the year to the very end of the year’ - Deuteronomy 11: 11-12.

Israel is God’s land, and He watches over it perpetually. That in itself is an amazing thought.

The biblically mandated land is much bigger than Israel is today and even much bigger than it would be if the proposed annexation took place.

‘Every place that the sole of your foot will tread upon I have given you, as I said to Moses. From the wilderness [the south of Israel] and this Lebanon [way north of Israel] as far as the great river, the River Euphrates [same as the modern day Euphrates], all the land of the Hittites, and to the Great Sea [Mediterranean Sea], toward the going down of the Sun, shall be your territory’ – Joshua 1:3-4.

Today, the River Euphrates flows through Turkey, Syria, and Iraq, and empties out into the Persian Gulf. No one believe that Israel should invade those areas today.

The restoration of the nation of Israel has been going on for 2000 years and is still in process. We do not know how it will be completely restored, but we are assured that God is constantly watching over His land.

Now to the question currently facing Israel and its leaders:

In the light of the biblical mandate, the PA’s desire to harm Israel, and the US political uncertainty, should Netanyahu’s administration unilaterally annex the Jewish settlements and Jordan Valley on 1st July?

In other words: Should they do it now, should they never consider such a move, or should they leave it until later?

Before I express my own views, I would like to remind all of us who believe in God and care deeply about this matter that first of all we should pray. Urgent prayer is needed .

The problem I have with annexing the land now is wrapped up in the problem I have with our Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, continuing to lead Israel while he is on trial for the serious criminal offences of bribery and corruption.

Yes, Benjamin Netanyahu has the right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty. That is not in dispute. But should any political leader be allowed to lead a nation while being tried for criminal offences?

I strongly say ‘no’. It is totally unacceptable.

With this in mind, Benjamin Netanyahu should not be the one making decisions about an annexation that will probably affect Israel and her international relationships for generations. It will likely lead to more bloodshed and war.

The problem is that critical decisions can be used to lever political power and strength that is not about the well-being of the nation, but the interests of the leader.

In the run up to his trial, Netanyahu has attacked the judiciary, the police, the prosecution counsel and the media. Although he is a defendant on trial, he is able to launch these attacks from a position of political power as the country’s Prime Minister.

This is not only unhealthy, but outright scandalous.

The government in Israel is a coalition of self-interest and mistrust. It is top heavy with expensive cabinet posts at a time of financial crisis around the world.

The facts on the ground are that Israel already has control of the Jordan Valley now. So, why go for annexation when the area is already under Israeli control? The same applies to the various Israeli settlements in Judea and Samaria.

Carrying out the annexation now will not significantly change realities on the ground. (Annexation would apply Israeli sovereignty to the disputed territories, but it would not change Israel’s current military control over these areas).

It makes political sense to wait. And it would be so much better if these critical decisions were made by an Israeli Prime Minister not mired in criminal proceedings.

So definitely not now!

So then, should Israel never annex these territories in Judea and Samaria and the Jordan Valley?

I certainly wouldn’t want these areas to ever be transferred to Palestinian control as part of some future peace deal.

The PA does not, and likely never will, recognize Israel’s right to exist. When Israel unilaterally pulled out of Gaza, all it got was Hamas rockets and terror. Israel should never cede land like this again.

Although the Trump plan is flawed in many respects, its value is that it shifts the debate quite correctly to examine the PA’s incitement of its children to hate and glorify terrorism, and to highlight Israel’s very real security needs.

Israel’ control of the Jordan Valley is the only way to ensure her ongoing security on the Jordanian border. To relinquish control would be strategic and military suicide.

So, I’m definitely not saying ‘never.’

Which leaves us with the option of ‘later.’

This maintains the security on the ground now, while calming the current frenzy sparked by Netanyahu’s annexation plans.

It allows the positive parts of the Trump Peace Plan to be digested and accepted as genuine and viable issues for Israel’s future security.

It also gives time for an untainted leadership to emerge in Israel that can respond to the challenges of Israel’s future without the self-interest and power grabbing that seems to motivate Netanyahu right now.

Finally, I believe with all my heart that God’s purposes for Israel, including the restoration of the land, and the restoration of its people into saving grace far outweighs all of the political intrigue currently being played out.

‘Behold, He who keeps Israel shall neither slumber nor sleep’ – Psalm 121:4.

I take God at His Word regarding Israel. Please join us in praying for justice, wisdom and right decisions that will eventually bless all the people affected.

Thank you for your prayers.

By Colin Mitchell 14 Mar, 2023
“But let justice run down like water, and righteousness like a mighty stream” - Amos 5:24 I have been in deep reflection for some considerable time about the current realities on the ground here in Israel, and how they relate to the nations, too. We are living in seriously challenging times, and all of us who believe in Yeshua are having to navigate our paths and responses both sensitively and with great discernment. My recent three-minute video alluded to these thoughts. In the video, I reference God’s word in Isaiah 59:14: “Justice is turned back, And righteousness stands afar off; For truth is fallen in the street, And equity cannot enter.” This verse has been gripping me for weeks. As David Davis, our founding pastor on Mt Carmel used to say, “I have been camping out” in Isaiah chapters 58, 59, and 60 for several weeks now. Isaiah 59:14 seems to sum up the current realities here in Israel. After five elections in a period of four years, the elected government, under the leadership of Benjamin Netanyahu, has within its ranks ultra-right-wing extremists who believe that Arabs should not even live in Israel. Itamar Ben Gvir, and Bezalel Smotrich have been given ministry posts in order to secure Netanyahu’s majority in the parliament. Itamar Ben Gvir is an extremist who openly supports Jewish terrorists such as Yaakov Teitel , the man sent to prison for 90 years for committing murder and for sending a bomb wrapped up in a Purim gift to a Messianic family in Ariel, Israel. The bomb exploded and seriously injured the family’s 15-year-old son, who miraculously survived but required more than 20 surgeries. Ben Gvir served as a lawyer in this case and declared, “we are all Yaakov Teitel” as he sought to justify his client’s murderous intent. Now Ben Gvir has been given authority over Israel’s police force by Prime Minister Netanyahu. A price Netanyahu paid to keep his coalition together, and to keep himself in power. If this isn’t bad enough, Bezalel Smotrich has been given authority over Judea and Samaria, the so called “West Bank.” In recent weeks, sixteen Israelis have been murdered by extreme Islamists. Two were slaughtered by a terrorist who lived in the Arab village of Huwara. The deaths of innocent Israelis continues to enflame the situation and wound the heart of every Jew in Israel, including mine. But this is no justification for the evil attack that Jewish extremists then carried out on Huwara. Jewish settlers nearby burned Arab homes and cars and murdered one resident. This inexcusable violence grieves the Jewish soul. Any self-respecting Jew knows that such barbaric acts committed by fellow Jews is disgraceful and completely alien to Jewish thinking. In a subsequent rant , Smotrich said that the Israeli army should “wipe out Huwara!” When he realized that his words had been recorded, Smotrich apologized! His apology was clearly a public relations exercise and didn’t reflect any genuine change of heart. Now you might react by asking, “Why doesn’t Netanyahu, (who historically is Israel’s longest serving Prime Minister with a legacy of service and an emphasis on security that has been worthy of respect) just sack Smotrich?” The answer is simple. Netanyahu needs these extremists and their parties for his majority in parliament. If he sacks Gvir or Smotrich, he loses his majority and he loses his power. I love Israel. I will continue to be an advocate for Israel and stand for God’s purposes for Israel and the Jewish people. That said, I also know that I represent the King of Kings and Lord of Lords, and His truth is sovereign. We who love Israel must be willing to speak out when injustice and hatred infiltrate our nation and government, and not just ignore issues because they make us feel uncomfortable. We cannot excuse such realities or just write them off as a politically inspired left-wing attempt to undermine a right-wing government, as some do. The protests in Israel have brought together hundreds of thousands of citizens across the political spectrum. They are an expression of how deeply unhappy the majority of the Israeli people are with the government’s attempt to neuter the State’s historically independent judiciary. We are called to pray for those in authority, and we do pray for all of our government ministers. But we must also speak out against evil and ungodly behaviour. In recent times I have listened intently to a very brave and courageous Arab woman who loves Yeshua and recognizes Israel’s covenant relationship with God, including the land covenant. At the same time, my Arab friend longs to see the Arab people grow in understanding and hope and is supporting educational initiatives among Arab youth and children. Education will always be critical in bringing about any positive change among people anywhere. As I listened, I was deeply convicted of the need for hope for Jews and Arabs alike and I will seek to practically and spiritually inspire and pray for such hope whenever I can. Even as tensions and violence increase in Israel, and indeed around the world, it is wonderful to identify powerful hope springing up in the midst of growing hatred and darkness. Isaiah declared this powerful hope in great contrast to the realities that existed as he spoke God’s words and revealed God’s heart. "Arise, shine; For your light has come! And the glory of the LORD is risen upon you. For behold, the darkness shall cover the earth, And deep darkness the people; But the LORD will arise over you, And His glory will be seen upon you." - Isaiah 60:1-2 People, arise! Get up! Shine! God’s glory and His resurrection power are risen upon us! Yes, the world is gloomy and spiritually bereft. But God’s promise to us is ringing out through His words. The Lord will arise over us and His glory will be seen upon us. This is God’s promise as we continue to long for justice and hope to prevail.
By Colin Mitchell 24 Nov, 2022
Early yesterday morning, the news came through of yet another dreadful terrorist atrocity that involved two bombs laden with nails and placed at two bus stop areas at the entrance to Jerusalem. I have driven on those very roads countless times. Later, it emerged that the first pronounced death from this attack was Aryeh Schupak, a dual Israeli/Canadian citizen who was on his way to religious studies. Aryeh was only 16 years old and was buried this afternoon in Jerusalem. Earlier in the night, a 16 year old Arab teenager, Ahmed Shehadeh was killed in Nablus. Ahmed was involved with other men in terrorist activities that were attempting to stop Jewish worshippers going to the tomb of Joseph. Two 16 year olds are dead. One Arab teenager who should be studying and looking forward to life, but was instead involved in extreme violence, paying the ultimate price, and a Jewish teenager who was on his way to Yeshiva to study, and had his life cruelly taken from him. Such losses are simply devastating. I was deeply affected by the news of the terrorist attack and, although I don’t want to be emotive or condemning in this article, I feel compelled to write as I see a clear unmistakable connection between the acts of terror that killed a perpetrator and a student within hours of each other, and the football World Cup in Qatar. Qatar is currently hosting the World Cup event with much fanfare, and many of my friends are caught up in the frenzy of the games. Everyone who knows me knows how much I love football, but when I heard that Qatar was being allowed to host the tournament, I and many others were outraged. The secular media has emphasized the anti LBGT stance of Qatar, and the shameful loss of life among migrant workers being paid a pittance to build the stadiums. They have primarily ignored Qatar’s funding of Hamas and Al Qaeda, and their clear anti-Semitism. Qatar’s history and current activities read like an unspeakable crime record. I decided some weeks ago that I would quietly boycott watching the tournament. The players have no choice but to participate, but as I wrote a few days ago on social media, I don’t have to watch it! I certainly didn’t want to be a killjoy by telling all my friends to join me in boycotting watching the games. Qatar funds Hamas, a terrorist organization based in Gaza that hates Israel and recruits young Arabs to commit acts of terror. Hamas and other similar groups were an inspiration for the 16-year-old Arab boy, Ahmed Shehadeh, whose terrorist activities ultimately led to the end of his young life. When the 16-year-old Jewish boy, Aryeh Schupak, was killed in the terrorist attack yesterday, Hamas were quick to rejoice. As I was reflecting on these disturbing realities, I felt that I must speak out my horror that so many people seem to be oblivious to the connections that are staring me in the face. I have watched every World Cup that has been played during my lifetime, but I cannot watch this legitimisation of a nation that it responsible for so much bloodshed. I cannot accept the notion that it is OK to turn a blind eye to these realities either. Please take a stand in prayer and intercede for the nation and people of Qatar. Pray for an increased awareness of these grim connections. Pray especially for those who are grieving the loss of two 16-year-old boys who should have their whole lives ahead of them, but today are gone! As Jews and Arabs are weeping, I cannot shout, “goal!”  Please pray for the peace of Jerusalem (Psalm 122:6).
By Colin Mitchell 27 Oct, 2022
It is often said that the greatest gifts come in small packages. In March 2020, after I finished speaking at the Sunday service in De Rivier Church in Gouda, Holland, an older woman came up to me and placed a small package in my hand, carefully wrapped in tissue paper. The woman was very emotional, and it was clear that she was giving me something precious. As I removed the tissue, I saw that I was holding a yad. The yad (or pointer) is used in synagogue services when the Torah scrolls are read. Readers use it to follow the text on the scroll and avoid putting their fingers on the parchment. The yad signifies the holiness of the Torah. It preserves the scrolls by preventing the damage that could be caused by human hands. This reverence for the Torah resonates deeply with all of us who hold the Bible as God’s Word and understand its holiness and the powerful truths contained within its pages. I have many childhood memories of attending my synagogue in East London and seeing the yad that was used there, including at my own bar mitzvah. 
Putin-Kremlin
By Colin Mitchell 13 Feb, 2022
Yesterday, here on Mount Carmel, I stood up to pray for the dangerous developments on the Ukraine/Russia border, and the serious and wide-ranging implications for the rest of the world. Our world stands on the precipice of events that could lead to a third world war.
By Colin Mitchell 22 Dec, 2021
“Then He arose and rebuked the wind, and said to the sea, ‘Peace, be still!’ And the wind ceased and there was a great calm.” Mark 4:39 Just two days ago, here in Israel, we received warnings of an approaching storm that duly arrived yesterday 20th December 2021, pouring much needed rain upon our dry land, but also threatening damage through very high gale force winds and severe floods. The Israeli media gave it the name, ‘The Carmel Storm’, so we prepared for its arrival in practical ways, prayed for God’s protection, and waited. The day before the storm, there was a quiet lull in the weather across the land, but we all knew the storm was coming! Back in November 2019, I was privileged to speak in Malaysia on the God-given theme of “The Coming Storm.” Here is a picture of the promotion for that event.
By Colin Mitchell 28 Aug, 2021
The reports and images we have been seeing from Afghanistan have given us just a glimpse of the evil and barbaric rule of the Taliban. The slaughter at Kabul airport has added to the sense of utter chaos and devastation. To see babies being handed over barbed wire fences by desperate parents to US and UK soldiers in Kabul airport to ensure their children’s escape is to witness an agony few of us will ever have to experience. It is unspeakable torment. It reminds me of the Jewish parents who sent their children from Nazi Germany on the Kindertransport to England to escape death in the concentration camps.
By Colin Mitchell 15 Jul, 2021
During the recent 11-day war with Gaza, during which Hamas fired over 5,000 rockets at my nation, Israel , and after the dreadful riots in several Israeli cities between minority groups of right-wing Jews and Arab Muslims, I was crying out to God from our home on the slopes of Mount Carmel.
By Colin Mitchell 09 Jun, 2021
Helen and I have now been living and serving in Israel for over twelve years, during which time, we have witnessed changes within Israel, and indeed further afield which can be likened to a massive shift in our world, of such seismic power it feels as if we are experiencing the effects of a massive earthquake.
By Colin Mitchell 19 May, 2021
For the upright will dwell in the land, And the blameless will remain in it; But the wicked will be cut off from the earth, And the unfaithful will be uprooted from it. - Proverbs 2: 21-22
By Colin Mitchell 08 Mar, 2021
The debate about the vaccines is alive and well here in Israel, as it is around the globe, and seems to be a heightened example of the very long-standing tensions that have always been evident among believers with regards to spiritual healing and medical treatment.
Show More
Share by: